NY Plain Ole Cheese
Finished with fresh Basil
Pizza Week 2026 Participant
Upper East Side · ManhattanThe Shop
The Story
On the Upper East Side, crust is the name of the game at Frico on 2nd, named for the caramelized cheese ring that borders every Detroit-style pie. The shop is helmed by owner and head pizzaiolo Jamie Culliton, a four-time World Champion Master Pizzaiolo, and it shows in the details: thick, square slices baked in traditional steel pans for crispy, cheddar-crusted edges and an airy, well-developed crumb inside. Toppings lean bold and gourmet — think meatballs, peppadew peppers, and piped-on ricotta — alongside a rotating weekly special slice that keeps regulars coming back. In a city built on thin-crust tradition, Frico on 2nd stands out for doing Detroit-style with real technique and no shortcuts.
Owner
Pizza Week Special Slice
Roasted garlic, roasted brussel sprouts, bacon cream sauce, pancetta.
The Special Slice
Other Customer Favorites
Finished with fresh Basil
Our Red Top Finished with House made Basil Pesto and Creamy Ricotta
Beef Meatballs, Italian Sausage and Pepperoni
Toasted Pistachios, Peppadew Peppers finished with Piped Ricotta, Hot Honey and Arugula